An Encyclopedia of Every Literary Plot, Ever by Boris Kachka

HOW TO PLOT A NOVEL August 10, 2016

An Encyclopedia of Every Literary Plot, Ever

By Boris Kachka

 

08-plot-encyclopedia-1.w529.h352.jpg

From Genesis to cyberpunk.

How many plots are there in fiction? Millions, two, or 36, depending on whom you ask. There’s William Wallace Cook’s chart-crazy Plotto, first published in 1928; there’s crisp guides like Christopher Booker’s The Basic Seven Plots and Ronald B. Tobias’s 20 Master Plots; there’s even a couple of computer programs — many, over centuries, have tried to count the ways to tell a story. With a little help from those, here is a far-from-comprehensive encyclopedia of every archetypal plot we know.

A

Adultery
Anna Karenina, by Leo Tolstoy; The End of the Affair, by Graham Greene;Little Children, by Tom Perrotta.
A perennial plot device that has survived the weakening of social taboos. What once caused shame and suicide now often ends in reconciliation. (see also: Forbidden Love.)

Adventure, Allegorical
The Chronicles of Narnia, by C. S. Lewis; The Master and Margaritaby Mikhail Bulgakov.
The current is closer to the surface in stories rife with symbolism, though in modern times it tends to be less on the nose.

Adventure, Natural
20,000 Leagues Under the Seaby Jules Verne; The Sea-Wolf, by Jack London.
A usually itinerant story in which action is the prime directive, even if deeper currents run below. (see also: Quest.)

C

Coming of Age
Great Expectationsby Charles Dickens; Huckleberry Finnby Mark Twain.
The bildungsroman, as the Germans call it.

Coming of Age, Artistic
A Portrait of the Artist As a Young Man, by James Joyce; The Fortress of Solitude, by Jonathan Lethem.
This subtype has its own German term, too: Künstlerroman.

Coming of Age, Group
The Group, by Mary McCarthy; The Interestingsby Meg Wolitzer; Private Citizens, by Tony Tulathimutte.
Characters converge — usually in high school or college — and then diverge. But changed!

The Con
Dead Soulsby Nikolai Gogol; If Tomorrow Comes, by Sidney Sheldon.
Who doesn’t want to root for a seasoned liar and criminal?

The Con Artist Gets Conned
The Grifters, by Jim Thompson; The Mark Insideby Amy Reading.
A swindler is double-crossed, either out of vengeance or greed. (see also:the ImpostorSpy-Versus-Spy Story.)

D

Death Plot
The Death of Ivan Ilyichby Leo Tolstoy.
Facing a slow demise or a pending execution, the condemned seeks absolution or a reckoning with the universe.

Death As MacGuffin
My Sister’s Keeperby Jodi Picoult; The Fault in Our Stars, by John Green.
The “wrong” person dies.

Descent Into Madness
Tender Is the Night, by F. Scott Fitzgerald; Mrs. Dalloway, by Virginia Woolf.
A character’s fall is described, sometimes luridly but often sympathetically.

Descent Into Addiction
The Lost Weekendby Charles Jackson; Trainspotting, by Irvine Welsh.
Same trajectory as madness, just add problematic glamour.

Discovery of Hidden Parentage
Great Expectations.
One of the most reliable plot twists, this one often changes the character’s self-identity, for better or worse.

Discovery of Incest
Dolores Claiborneby Stephen King; A Song of Ice and Fireby George R.R. Martin
This tends to have grave plot consequences, like murder and succession crises.

Discovery of a Lie
The Portrait of a Lady, by Henry James.
The protagonist is deceived through much of the story until the scales fall from her eyes. Like coming-of-age stories, it pivots on a revelation, but here the knowledge was purposely hidden from the protagonist — or in some cases, as in Gone Girl, by the protagonist.

Discovery of the Secretly Alive
Romeo and Julietby William Shakespeare; Our Mutual Friendby Charles Dickens.
It sounds like a happy surprise, but this late twist doesn’t always turn out to be a good thing.

Discovery of the Secretly Nonexistent
Fight Clubby Chuck Palahniuk; Odd Thomasby Dean Koontz.
Wherein people turn out to see dead people — or imaginary ones.

Domesticity Meltdown
A Doll’s House, by Henrik Ibsen; Revolutionary Road, by Richard Yates.
Someone, usually a woman, finds her home life unbearable and takes or contemplates extreme measures. (see also: Wife As Phoenix.)

E

Estate Division
A Perfectly Good Family, by Lionel Shriver.
A family gathers in the wake of the death of parents to figure out what to do with their effects; old conflicts resurface. (see also: Family Reunion.)

F

Family Reunion
This Is Where I Leave Youby Jonathan Tropper; Maineby J. Courtney Sullivan.
A vacation or a death brings a far-flung family together; old conflicts resurface.

Family Saga
Buddenbrooksby Thomas Mann; Homegoingby Yaa Gyasi.
Where many ambitious novels bring contemporaneous stories together, this megaplot tracks a single clan across a broad sweep of time. (see also:Rise and Fall.)

Forbidden Love, Tragic
Romeo and Juliet; Anna Karenina.
A deep infatuation whose obstacle is a feud or social taboo that ends very badly. (see also: Love Thwarted and Mourned.)

Forbidden Love, Triumphant
Water for Elephantsby Sara Gruen; Fifty Shades Freed, by E. L. James.
Love conquers all — abusive husbands and sad billionaires alike.

G

Good-Guy-Bad-Guy Alliance
To Catch a Thief, by David Dodge; The Silence of the Lambs, by Thomas Harris.
A cop or other white-hat teams up with a criminal to fight an even greater evil, forming an unstable and unpredictable team.

I

The Impostor
The Talented Mr. Ripleyby Patricia Highsmith; Six Degrees of Separationby John Guare.
An anti-hero assumes a false identity and succeeds — to a point. Sometimes the question of whether he’ll evade detection is left unresolved (or deferred to sequels and/or film adaptations).

Innocent’s Tale
Roomby Emma Donoghue; The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, by Mark Haddon.
A child (or childlike) narrator can only tell a part of the story, leaving the reader to figure out the rest. (see also: Coming of Age.)

Insane Narrator
Fight Club; Life of Pi, by Yann Martel.
The unveiling of deception or hallucination by a seemingly trustworthy narrator becomes a perspective-shifting plot twist. There’s an open-ended version: Is she crazy? Was it a dream?

K

The Knausgaard
My Struggleby Karl Ove Knausgaard; The Wavesby Virginia Woolf.
Here named for Knausgaard’s six-volume epic of seemingly unedited episodes from his life, this category of anti-narrative isn’t quite plotless. For Woolf, it meant following consciousness where it goes, tracking the way the mind jumbles and reorders time. For Knausgaard, it meant repeatedly making tea.

L

Love Story: The Hate Plot
The Dance of Deathby August Strindberg; Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?by Edward Albee
A curdled kind of love creates tension, ambiguity, and great zingers. It’s the kind of tragedy you hate to love.

Love Story: The Marriage Plot
Pride and Prejudiceby Jane Austen; Jane Eyreby Charlotte Brontë.
Traditionally, a woman turns down proposals of convenience and settles on an unexpected Mr. Right. While Austen’s “truth universally acknowledged” — that marriage is the end-all and be-all — is on its way out, the plot seems to endure, albeit with an ironic gloss. Helen Fielding’sBridget Jones’s Diary was only one of a slew of homages to the love plot, updated for a more confusing and equitable era — including Jeffrey Eugenides’s The Marriage Plot. (see also: Forbidden Love.)

Love Story: Obsession
Othello, by William Shakespeare; Lolitaby Vladimir Nabokov.
An excess of love, sometimes less than mutual, drives the lover to violence or corruption, damaging the lover and/or the beloved.

Love Thwarted and Mourned
Love in the Time of Cholera, by Gabriel García Márquez; The Age of Innocenceby Edith Wharton.
A doomed or stillborn affair ends not in tragedy but in compromise, regret, and many wistful looks. (see also:
Forbidden Love.)

08-plot-encyclopedia-2.w529.h352.jpg

M

Me Against the Apocalypse
The Standby Stephen King; The Roadby Cormac McCarthy.
The universe being opposed is in rapid decline, and the struggle isn’t against order but disorder (whether in the form of environmental collapse, nuclear winter, plague, or some other global comeuppance).

Me Against Machine
I, Robotby Isaac Asimov; Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?by Philip K. Dick.
The technology we invented has broken loose and the resulting sci-fi adventure story usually doubles as a techno-skeptical dystopia.

Me Against the World
The Hunger Gamesby Suzanne Collins; Nineteen Eighty-Four, by George Orwell; The Strangerby Albert Camus.
One person resists an immovable power and either triumphs or submits. In dystopian fiction, that power tends to be an authoritarian government. The existentialists raised the stakes by pitting an individual against an unfeeling universe.

Metamorphosis, Internal
Pygmalionby George Bernard Shaw; Catch-22by Joseph Heller.
Someone is put through a trial by transformation — which can yield unexpected results (Eliza Doolittle’s independent streak).

Metamorphosis, Magical
Draculaby Bram Stoker; The Metamorphosisby Franz Kafka.
The (anti-)hero suffers from a transformative curse — a spell that can only be broken by love or death.

Missing Person
Where’d You Go, Bernadetteby Maria Semple.
Lots of things can happen to people who disappear, which is also what you want from a plot.

Mistaken Identity
Our Mutual FriendScoopby Evelyn Waugh.
An essential misunderstanding or deliberate deception drives the story in surprising directions. (see also: Discovery of the Secretly Alive.)

Mystery: Locked Room
Murder on the Orient Expressby Agatha Christie.
Whodunits were often classified as “riddle plots” by early plot anatomists, and the Platonic exemplar of the riddle is the “locked room” variety: Owing to circumstances laid out by the author, there are a finite number of suspects to a crime, and the reader’s job is the same as the detective’s: Figure it out from the available clues.

Mystery: Existential
The Trialby Franz Kafka.
The puzzle is unsolvable, because the riddle is our unknowable and often hostile universe. (see also: Me Against the World.)

Mystery: Mirror Version
The Whitesby Richard Price.
The criminal’s identity is revealed early on, so the reader knows more than the detective (but not enough to know what happens next).

Mystery: Open-Ended
The Big Sleepby Raymond Chandler.
Chandler once wrote that half of all mystery books break the rule that all the tools for solving a murder should be clearly laid out. Enter the MacGuffin and other red herrings, complicated heroes who lie or mess up or just drink a lot. (see also: QuestMacGuffin VariationPursuit, Conflicted.)

Mystery: Ticking Clock
The Silence of the Lambs.
The riddle must be solved in time to prevent the next heist, murder, or terrorist attack.

How Much Does Plot Matter, Anyway.png

 

P

Pandora’s Box
Frankensteinby Mary Shelley; Jurassic Parkby Michael Crichton.
Scientists aim to advance technology in some way, and of course it backfires, because nature can’t be tamed. (see also: Me Against the Apocalypse.)

Parallel Stories
The comedies of Shakespeare; Kafka on the Shoreby Haruki Murakami.
The plot is broken up among several sets of characters, whose conflicts are related but independent.

Picaresque
Don Quixoteby Miguel de Cervantes; On the Roadby Jack Kerouac.
Our (often roguish and working-class) hero moves from adventure to adventure or quest to quest, usually without maturing too much. Its modern American version favors the road trip. (see also: Tall Tales.)

Pursuit
Jawsby Peter Benchley; The Hunt for Red October, by Tom Clancy.
Usually both a riddle and a chase, this action-heavy plot proceeds with a logical structure and noble, objective hero.

Pursuit, Moral-Ambiguity Variation
Les Misérablesby Victor Hugo; The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo, by Stieg Larsson.
A procedural or law-and-order drama is heightened when the righteous pursuer blurs ethical lines. (see also: Mystery: Open-Ended.)

Q

Quest, Classic

Don QuixoteThe Grapes of Wrathby John Steinbeck.
Both a pursuit and an adventure, but always with a tangible, redemptive goal.

Quest, MacGuffin Variation
The Maltese Falconby Dashiell Hammett; The Goldfinch, by Donna Tartt.
The object of the quest turns out to be a distraction, initiating the plot before giving way to the real drama. A MacGuffin can be any plot device that is superseded by a more important pursuit. (see also: Mystery: Open-ended.)

R

Rags to Riches
Oliver Twistby Charles Dickens; The Fountainheadby Ayn Rand; What Makes Sammy Run?by Budd Schulberg.
Older examples might have involved sheer luck, but in more modern stories, the driver of mobility is ambition, whether celebrated or satirized.

Rashomon
The Sound and the Furyby William Faulkner; Imagine Me Goneby Adam Haslett.
Named for the Kurosawa movie, in which four witnesses offer conflicting versions of a murder, it’s the same narrative retold from different perspectives. (see also: Symphony Story.)

Rescue
The Princess Bride, by William Goldman; The Hard Wayby Lee Child.
Essentially a quest with a person at the end of it — a prisoner who has little agency in the story. (see also: PursuitQuest.)

Revenge
Hamletby William Shakespeare; The Count of Monte Cristoby Alexandre Dumas.
The wronged protagonist finds his way to avenging injustice, usually by extralegal means.

Revenge, Excessive
The Cask of Amontilladoby Edgar Allan Poe; Medeaby Euripides.
The revenge plot with a heavy dose of crazy. Either the original slight is invented or magnified, or the vengeance is so out of whack (Medea’s murder of her own children) that all reason is left behind.

Rise and Fall
The Godfatherby Mario Puzo; One Hundred Years of Solitudeby Gabriel García Márquez.
A long story arc follows a person or a family to great heights and depths, often as the result of morally questionable choices along the way. (See also: TragedyFamily Saga.)

The Rise of One, the Fall of Another
Sister Carrieby Theodore Dreiser; The Prince and the Pauperby Mark Twain.
The wheel of fortune turns, and one hero is brought low, the other high. If the one raised up is good, the moral is bright; if vice versa, we end up in a dark place.

Rivalry of Equals
Paradise Lostby John Milton; Moby-Dickby Herman Melville.
The fighters in the story need not be physically evenly matched; in fact, they work best when strengths are complementary (brains versus brawn, darkness versus light).

Rivalry of Unequals
“Cinderella”; One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nestby Ken Kesey.
Underdog plots go back at least to the Bible. They’re rivalry stories in which one (usually more righteous) party is weaker in almost all respects.

Rivalry of Unequals, Jealousy Variation
The Informationby Martin Amis; Amadeusby Peter Shaffer.
Envy is at the root of such rivalries, and the underdog isn’t the noble hero but the embittered loser.

Romantic Comedy
Shakespeare’s comedies; Can You Keep a Secret?by Sophie Kinsella.
Overcoming obstacles, the right people find each other and the mismatched are realigned. (see also: The Marriage Plot.)

S

Spy Story
The Quiet Americanby Graham Greene; Martin Cruz Smith’s novels.
Espionage thrillers contain plenty of riddles and ticking clocks, but they also encompass other story elements: globe-trotting pursuit, geopolitical intrigue, and layers of social history.

Spy-Versus-Spy Story
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spyby John le Carré.
Spies often fight to outsmart and set traps for each other, and here the rivalry might even supersede the greater goal of intelligence gathering.

Symphony Story
White Teethby Zadie Smith; Underworld, by Don DeLillo; Ragtime, by E. L. Doctorow.
Several narratives intersect, collide, and sometimes culminate in a grand resolution meant to capture a larger societal moment. James Wood derided some of it as “hysterical realism.”

Stalker
Into the Darkest Cornerby Elizabeth Haynes; Sweet Lamb of Heavenby Lydia Millet.
The Lifetime staple of story lines is diabolically simple: A man won’t stop tormenting a woman until one of them dies. But there are variations …

Stalker, Caretaker Variation
Miseryby Stephen King; Notes on a Scandalby Zoë Heller.
Often the predator is a single woman who becomes enmeshed with a man or family in a caretaking situation, then begins entertaining fantasies of making things permanent — sometimes by lethal force. (see also: Love Story: Obsession.)

T

Tall Tales
The Decameronby Giovanni Boccaccio; One Thousand and One Nights;The Canterbury Talesby Geoffrey Chaucer.
Many “nested stories” are told or written by characters within the larger narrative, often becoming more important than the loose plot that frames them.

Tragedy
Hamlet; Oedipus Rex, by Sophocles.
Tragedies in the Aristotelian sense involve the downfall of a hero whose greatest weakness (which also may be a strength) makes defeat and disaster inevitable.

 

Trial
To Kill a Mockingbirdby Harper Lee; A Time to Killby John Grisham.
Somewhere between a genre and a plot device, the court case can be the central story or an event that clarifies social issues surrounding the alleged crime.

Trial by Suffering
The Book of Job; A Little Lifeby Hanya Yanagihara.
Troubles are heaped upon our protagonist until he is left irreparably disillusioned or dead — perhaps with just a hint of redemption at the end. (see also: Rise and Fall.)

Trial, Show
The Crucibleby Arthur Miller; Darkness at Noonby Arthur Koestler.
Stories of witch hunts, literal and otherwise, might revolve around a courtroom trial or may more broadly feature mob justice, like Shirley Jackson’s The Lottery.

The Scarlet Letter in the Tinder Era.jpg

V

Voyage and Return
Typeeby Herman Melville; Alice’s Adventures in Wonderlandby Lewis Carroll; The Wonderful Wizard of Ozby L. Frank Baum.
A kind of accidental quest: The goal is return, but the pleasure is in exploring a strange new world. (see also: Adventure.)

Voyage, Return As MacGuffin
Robinson Crusoeby Daniel Defoe; The Martian, by Andy Weir; Lord of the Fliesby William Golding.
The stranded adventurer’s escape is deferred and the plot stalls into a sort of social locked-room mystery. Will the hero survive? Can he remake society? (see also: QuestMacGuffin Variation.)

W

War at the Front
Catch-22For Whom the Bell Tolls, by Ernest Hemingway; War and Peaceby Leo Tolstoy.
Bloody conflict gives the story its structure, whether the attitude toward it is heroic, comic, or deeply critical (or all three!).

War on the Home Front
Cold Mountain, by Charles Frazier; War and Peace.
The effects of war and revolution are felt by those left behind; families are torn asunder and/or reunited.

Wife As Phoenix
Gone Girlby Gillian Flynn; Fates and Furiesby Lauren Groff.
The story might begin with the wife mute or absent, or in any event cast in the role of long-suffering innocent. Then the narrative pivots, and as she tells her story, someone stronger and more calculating emerges.

*A version of this article appears in the August 8, 2016 issue of New York Magazine.

 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s